Bay Shore, New York.
Bay Shore sits on Long Island's mainland South Shore, facing Great South Bay and the western communities of Fire Island. Its Main Street dining scene and restored performance venue make it useful for more than a hurried transfer. A walk along Maple Avenue also brings local history into a route many visitors know only as the way to the ferry.
Photo credits1
- Depicts: Bay Shore, New YorkBayshore Marina. Author: Praiseandworship (Transfered by Bobby122 ). Credit: Original uploaded on en.wikipedia. License: CC BY 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0). Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Bayshore_Marina.JPGCropped to fit the display.
Make your way to Bay Shore, New York
Choose a tool and your dates to check the options for your trip.
More ways to explore
- Country
- United States
- Currency
- USD
- Time zone
- America/New York
Bay Shore sits on Long Island's mainland South Shore, facing Great South Bay and the western communities of Fire Island. Its Main Street dining scene and restored performance venue make it useful for more than a hurried transfer. A walk along Maple Avenue also brings local history into a route many visitors know only as the way to the ferry.
This is the mainland hamlet, not Ocean Beach or Ocean Bay Park across the water. Choose whether you want a Bay Shore evening, a day on Fire Island or a broader West Bay Shore outing, then match the transport and accommodation to that plan. Ferry terminals change by community and season, and the railway is a separate walk or taxi ride from the docks.
When to go
Summer increases the usefulness of Bay Shore as a beach gateway, but also brings full ferry parking lots and busy weekends. Autumn and winter still offer the Boulton's dated indoor programme and local history visits on their specified days. Sagtikos announces holiday house tours separately from its regular season. Fire Island timetables reduce and change: the reviewed Kismet schedule ends on 8 November 2026 with no later schedule published, while Saltaire already has a late-fall timetable with holiday exclusions.
Getting there
The Long Island Rail Road serves Bay Shore on the Montauk branch. The ferry operator describes about a mile south from the station to its Maple Avenue docks, with paid taxi transfers also available. Match the community to the exact sailing: Main Terminal is 99 Maple Avenue, West Terminal 104 Maple Avenue, and the Saltaire terminal is separate. Current fall Kismet and Saltaire timetables explicitly direct all trips to Main Terminal, overriding a broad summer terminal description. Sayville and Patchogue ferries serve different parts of Fire Island.
Getting around
Walk between the station, downtown and the appropriate waterfront when luggage and mobility permit. Allow extra time for road crossings, ticket purchase and the correct terminal gate. A taxi helps with bags or a late arrival, but reserve enough margin for the last boat. For Sagtikos and Gardiner County Park, plan a separate westward land journey. Once across the bay, passenger ferries and local walking routes replace the ordinary mainland road network; confirm the return community before setting out.
Local food
Main Street gives you a genuine dining stop before or after an island trip. Salt and Barrel at 61 West Main Street specialises in oysters and coastal food. The local restaurant committee also lists Frank & Maria's Italian Market at 10 West Main Street, North Fork Doughnut Co. at 5 East Main Street, and Mexican dining at Pecado on West Main. Pick up modest picnic supplies when needed, but consult ferry freight restrictions before arriving with bulk groceries or an oversized cooler.
What to see
The Bay Shore Historical Society's Gibson-Mack-Holt House at 22 Maple Avenue presents local museum exhibits and a reference library, with published Tuesday and Saturday visiting. The Boulton Center on West Main Street hosts concerts, comedy and community events in a former cinema that reopened as a performance venue in 2023. Farther west, Sagtikos Manor connects family history with George Washington's 1790 visit. Its regular 2026 house tours have ended until May 2027, while grounds and separately announced holiday visits follow different arrangements.
Towns and neighbourhoods
Main Street is the practical downtown spine for a meal and a show. Fourth Avenue connects the railway side of town with Maple Avenue towards the ferry waterfront. South Clinton Avenue leads to Bay Shore Marina Park, a different waterfront approach used for some seasonal Atlantique departures. West Bay Shore contains Sagtikos Manor and Gardiner County Park, both additional outings beyond the compact downtown circuit. Do not confuse these mainland locations with the pedestrian communities on the barrier island.
Coast and outdoors
Gardiner County Park offers nature trails towards Great South Bay, with woodland, a playground and a shoreline setting. A county description identifies dirt and mulch paths, so footwear and conditions matter more than a simple distance estimate. Leashed dogs are allowed under the park's rules. Bay Shore Marina Park and Benjamin Beach provide a separate town waterfront at South Clinton Avenue. Confirm seasonal facilities and access terms with the town; a mainland bay beach is different from the Atlantic surf reached by ferry.
Where to stay
A mainland stay suits travellers who want an evening meal or performance without depending on a late island crossing. Ocean Bay House at 69 Ocean Avenue is a waterfront bed and breakfast on Watchogue Creek, close to the ferry area; its historic building has individual rooms, so verify the access arrangement you need. A room farther inland may work with a car but requires a dock transfer. Accommodation on Fire Island is a different choice and depends on reaching the correct island community before the final sailing.
Useful before you go
Ferry parking is first come, with outside lots operating under their own terms; an ordinary downtown space is not automatically suitable for an overnight island stay. Mobile ferry tickets should be activated only when ready to board. The operator says its passenger boats have no toilets, so use terminal facilities first. Large freight and bicycles have separate restrictions rather than an automatic passenger allowance. For Gardiner's paths, use insect protection and check for ticks after the walk, following the county's practical guidance.
Good to know before you go
Is Bay Shore on Fire Island?
No. It is the mainland gateway on Long Island. Ocean Beach, Kismet and other island communities require the relevant crossing.
Does every ferry leave from 99 Maple Avenue?
No. Terminal assignments vary. The current fall Kismet and Saltaire schedules say Main Terminal, but other seasons and communities use different docks.
Can I walk from the train to the ferry?
The operator describes about a mile along Fourth Avenue and Maple Avenue. A paid taxi transfer is another option.
Are Sagtikos Manor's regular tours currently running?
The owner says the 2026 season has ended and ordinary tours resume in May 2027. Grounds and separately announced holiday tours have different access.
Can I stay overnight on the mainland?
Yes. Ocean Bay House is one documented waterfront option; check the room location and your transfer to the correct dock.
Is there something to do without taking a ferry?
Combine the historical society, a Main Street meal and a dated Boulton performance, or make a separate visit to Gardiner County Park.
Sources & references
These references support the guide. Confirm opening hours, access and travel services before you go.
- 01Historical society: Gibson-Mack-Holt House and visiting days
- 02Theatre owner: historic downtown venue and 2023 reopening
- 03Theatre owner: current autumn and winter programme
- 04Museum owner: ordinary tours ended until May 2027, holiday exceptions and grounds
- 05Historical society: estate and Washington visit
- 06County: Great South Bay nature park and entrance
- 07County 2026 walk: dirt and mulch trails, leashed dogs and tick preparation
- 08Town public parks directory: Marina Park and Benjamin Beach on South Clinton Avenue
- 09Restaurant owner: oyster bar at 61 West Main Street
- 10Local restaurant committee: Italian market, cafés and dining locations
- 11Ferry owner: distinct terminals, station walk, tickets and onboard facilities
- 12Ferry owner: current fall trips use Main Terminal, no later Kismet schedule yet
- 13Ferry owner: late-fall service and holiday exclusions
- 14NPS: separate mainland gateways for different island communities
- 15MTA: station facilities and accessibility
- 16Ferry owner: capacity-limited parking, external lots and paid rail transfer
- 17Lodging owner: Watchogue Creek bed and breakfast at 69 Ocean Avenue
- 18Ferry owner: separate freight arrangements
Where could the journey go next?
More guides in United States. Compare the places and check actual connections before combining stops.
Photo credits3
- Area image: Leaving the beach house and heading back to the car. — Area near KismetFire Island Kismet 10. Author: Peter Dutton from Forest Hills, Queens, USA. Credit: Heading Out. License: CC BY 2.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0). Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fire_Island_Kismet_10.jpgCropped to fit the display.
- Depicts: Fair HarborFair Harbor FD East Side 2. Author: ContinueWithCaution. Credit: Own work. License: CC BY-SA 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0). Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fair_Harbor_FD_East_Side_2.jpgCropped to fit the display.
- Area image: Fire Island, NY, USA — Area near Fire Island / DunewoodFire Island, NY, USA - panoramio (4). Author: dans362. Credit: https://web.archive.org/web/20161017234644/http://www.panoramio.com/photo/46657664. License: CC BY 3.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0). Source: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Fire_Island,_NY,_USA_-_panoramio_(4).jpgCropped to fit the display.